Musings on Mormonism



Tradeoffs

This world is full of tradeoffs – diametric values, ideals, or positions whose increase seems to inevitably come at the expense of its opposite. What follows are a few of my favorites (which is to say, they are interesting and fairly relevant); what are some of yours?

Economics

Equity vs. Efficiency: Putting resources (human or material) to use in a way that optimizes productive output (high efficiency) generally leads to the unequal distribution of said output (low equity). Conversely, allocating resources in a more egalitarian manner, e.g. redistributing income across classes, or assigning people to a task indiscriminate of skill level (high equity) tends to lead to decreased productivity, e.g. the incentive of the most productive economic actors is hampered by their lessened enjoyment of the fruits of their labors, or lower total skill level applied towards a task (low efficiency), respectively.

Political Science

Freedom vs. Order: This one is pretty self-evident. The fewer restrictions placed on behavior, the more chaotic and disorderly things tends to be. Just look at any household with a disparate ratio of children to parenting presence.

Freedom vs. Equality: This is one I had never considered until I read it in one of my brother’s old political science textbooks recently. The idea behind this is that a government/society which seeks to promote equality generally does so at the expense of individual freedom (e.g. affirmative action in the work place curbs the freedom of the employer to make its own hiring decisions). I’m still thinking this tradeoff through – it seems to be based on the premise that freedom invariably leads to inequal treatment of others, but this may or may not actually be true, depending on your definition of “equal”. The tendency in today’s debates is to frame “equality” as absolute sameness, which I think is absurd and impossible, not to mention not the only possible definition of “equality”.

Personality Psychology (it’s no secret that this topic is one of my favorites, but I offer this tradeoff by way of subjective observation, not judgment)

Depthiness vs. Upbeatfulness: Emotional and/or intellectual depth and sophistication tends to preclude being lighthearted and fun (when you’re focused on the weightier matters of the cosmos, jocularity can seem distant and disingenuous). On the flip side, what’s the use of sitting around ruminating in your ivory tower when there’s so much life to enjoy!

Christianity

Justice vs. Mercy: The quintessential Christian dilemma, this dichotmoy is, I believe, reflected throughout various facets of life, including the areas above. But it can be troublingly problematic. If we believe in a God who adheres strictly to divine standards and can neither overlook any bad behavior nor leave unrewarded the acts of the true and faithful (justice), can we believe that that same God can also forgive us when we inevitably fail to live those high standards, if not fall far, far short (mercy)? Stephen E. Robinson, author of “Believing Christ” said it best: the answer is a resounding “YES”! Jesus Christ, as the mediator of all mankind, provides a way for the demands of justice to be met while offering mercy to those who truly want Him to be their savior. Strangely and sadly enough, there are some who would gladly take mercy, but only if it came with no strings attached; such people, I think, fail to grasp the significance of either justice or mercy. But the most important thing here is that Jesus Christ makes both justice and mercy fully efficacious and coexistent without requiring any sort of compromise which would render either divine standard arbitrary and fatally unreliable. What an inestimable blessing!

(as an added temporal benefit, this divine reconciliation of opposing ideals gives me hope that the other above mentioned tradeoffs may also somehow be settled satisfactorily.)

Any thoughts or tradeoffs of your own to share? Please do!

Advertisements

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

Comments

  1. * Mish says:

    Enlightening post, bro! Not gonna lie, some of that stuff is way above my head, but I do think that concerning depthiness v. upbeatfulness, it is possible to exhibit both in their own rightful season. No one is only depthy or only upbeat all the time, right? And isn’t it possible to be depthy and upbeat simultaneously? Upbeat and excited about depth? Doesn’t a resounding “YES!” qualify as such? Speaking of that, did I tell you I’ve been taking Stephen E.’s New Testament class this semester? He is awesome.
    Keep up the good work!

    | Reply Posted 8 years, 5 months ago
    • * Bryce says:

      Thanks for the great comment, my main-Mish-man! I admit, my posts do tend to be a bit too esoteric (good GRE word, go look it up!). Believe me, if I had a cute wife and cute kids, I’d write a lot about them instead 🙂 But yeah, as far as being deep versus being upbeat, I do think it’s possible for a person to develop both qualities, and I think you’re right on in saying that no one can be only one way all the time. But to develop both to a high degree seems somewhat uncommmon, or at least takes a lot of time and effort; by “a high degree”, I mean that it is a consistent enough character trait that an outside observer might comment on it being an apparent facet of a person’s personality, and not just a fleeting, circumstantial mood. But also, I do think it’s possible for people to be upbeat and excited about depth, as you mentioned (I tend to prefer the company of such people). Thanks for keeping me honest and helping me refine my stances!

      As for Stephen E., that guy is awesome! He wasn’t doing too well when I took his class – how is he doing now? I’m looking forward to hearing about your experiences with that class.

      | Reply Posted 8 years, 5 months ago


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: